Choosing a roast shouldn’t feel like a gamble. The “best” roast depends on how you brew—because each method extracts coffee differently. This guide helps you match roast level to your brew method so your cup tastes cleaner, sweeter, and more consistent.
Quick Answer
For the easiest, most forgiving results at home, start with medium to medium-dark. You’ll get sweetness and body without the smoky edge of very dark roasts.
Complent approach: We focus on medium to medium-dark because it gives you the widest “dial-in” range across brew methods.
Why Roast Level Matters
Roast level changes how coffee behaves during extraction. Darker roasts extract more easily and quickly—often bringing more bitterness and roast flavor. Lighter roasts can taste brighter and more complex, but they’re less forgiving if grind, temperature, or time is off.
- Light: brighter, origin-forward, can be tricky to extract evenly.
- Medium: balanced, sweet, most versatile and forgiving.
- Medium-dark: richer body, chocolate/caramel notes, great for immersion and milk drinks.
- Very dark: smoky/roasty, less origin character, narrower “sweet spot.”
Match Roast to Your Brew Method
Drip Coffee
Best with medium to medium-dark for everyday sweetness and reliability.
Use the recipe here: The Perfect Drip Coffee Recipe
French Press
Best with medium-dark (and sometimes medium) for a richer, rounder cup.
Use the recipe here: The Perfect French Press Recipe
AeroPress
Best with medium for clean cups, and medium-dark for espresso-style strength.
See both recipes: AeroPress: Clean vs Espresso-Style
Espresso
Best with medium-dark for most home setups (easier dialing and better milk pairing).
Dial-in help: Espresso Dialing at Home
Cold Brew
Best with medium to medium-dark for smooth sweetness and low bitterness.
Use the recipe here: Cold Brew Coffee (Smooth, Low Bitterness)
Want the simplest, most versatile roast?
Medium and medium-dark are the easiest to brew consistently across methods.
Explore our coffees →